Compliance
Red Flags Rule for Car Dealers: Identity Theft Program
Whether the FTC Red Flags Rule covers your dealership, the four elements of a written Identity Theft Prevention Program, and the red flags to watch for.
Key takeaways
- The Red Flags Rule requires creditors that offer or maintain covered accounts, a category whose examples include automobile loans, to have a written Identity Theft Prevention Program.
- Since the Red Flag Program Clarification Act of 2010, a “creditor” is one that regularly obtains or uses consumer reports, reports to credit bureaus, or advances funds in connection with credit. A dealer that finances its own customers usually fits.
- The program must identify relevant red flags, detect them, respond to them, and be updated periodically. The owner or senior management approves it, staff get trained, and service providers are overseen.
- The Safeguards Rule is about protecting customer data you hold. The Red Flags Rule is about spotting someone using a stolen identity to open or use an account. Most financing dealers need both.
In this article
The Red Flags Rule requires a creditor that offers or maintains “covered accounts” to have a written Identity Theft Prevention Program. The program’s job is to spot the warning signs that someone is opening or using an account with a stolen identity, and to respond. Automobile loans are one of the rule’s own examples of a covered account, so a dealer that finances customers, and especially a Buy Here Pay Here dealer that carries its own contracts, should assume the rule applies and confirm it with counsel.
Is your dealership a “creditor”?
The rule (16 C.F.R. Part 681, § 681.1) applies to financial institutions and creditors that are subject to FTC enforcement of the Fair Credit Reporting Act. It borrows its definition of “creditor” from the statute, which was narrowed by the Red Flag Program Clarification Act of 2010. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681m(e)(4), a creditor is a creditor under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act that, regularly and in the ordinary course of business, does at least one of these:
- Obtains or uses consumer reports, directly or indirectly, in connection with a credit transaction.
- Furnishes information to consumer reporting agencies in connection with a credit transaction.
- Advances funds to or on behalf of a person, based on that person’s obligation to repay, or repayable from property they pledged.
The Equal Credit Opportunity Act definition covers anyone who regularly extends, renews or continues credit, anyone who regularly arranges for credit, and certain assignees who take part in the credit decision. The 2010 law excludes a creditor that only advances funds for expenses incidental to a service it provides.
For a dealership, the practical tests are simple. Do you pull credit reports on applicants? Do you report payment history to the credit bureaus? Do you carry your own installment contracts? A BHPH dealer usually answers yes to at least one. A dealer that only arranges financing with outside lenders should work through the definitions with counsel.
Do you have covered accounts?
A covered account is an account you offer or maintain, primarily for personal, family or household purposes, that involves or is designed to permit multiple payments or transactions. The rule lists an automobile loan as an example. It also includes any other account with a reasonably foreseeable risk of identity theft to customers or to your business.
The rule requires you to determine periodically whether you offer or maintain covered accounts. As part of that, you assess risk based on how accounts are opened, how they are accessed, and your past experience with identity theft. Write that determination down; it is the first page of your program.
The four elements of the written program
| Element | What it means at a dealership |
|---|---|
| Identify relevant red flags | List the warning signs that fit your accounts: how customers apply, how they pay, and what fraud you have seen. |
| Detect red flags | Put steps in place to catch them: checking ID at the desk, reviewing credit report alerts, verifying address changes on existing accounts. |
| Respond appropriately | Decide in advance what staff do when a red flag appears, matched to the level of risk. |
| Update periodically | Review the program as risks, fraud methods, your accounts and your service providers change. |
Owner approval, training and service providers
- Approval: the board of directors, or an appropriate board committee, must approve the initial written program. If your business has no board, the rule treats a designated employee at the level of senior management as the board.
- Oversight: the board or a senior manager must be involved in developing, implementing and administering the program.
- Training: train staff as necessary to carry out the program. At a dealership that means salespeople, F&I and whoever takes payments.
- Service providers: exercise appropriate and effective oversight of providers that perform activities connected to covered accounts. The guidelines suggest requiring them by contract to detect and report red flags or take steps to prevent identity theft.
- Reporting: the guidelines say staff responsible for the program should report to the board or senior management at least annually on how it is working, service-provider arrangements, significant incidents and recommended changes.
Red flags a dealer might see
The rule’s Supplement A lists 26 illustrative red flags in five categories (16 C.F.R. Part 681, Appendix A). You must consider the guidelines and include those that fit your business. These are the ones most relevant to a car lot:
| Category | Examples |
|---|---|
| Alerts from a consumer reporting agency | A fraud or active duty alert on the credit report; a notice of credit freeze; a notice of address discrepancy; a sudden jump in inquiries or new credit accounts. |
| Suspicious documents | An ID that looks altered or forged; a photo or description that does not match the person at the desk; ID details that do not match the application; an application that looks altered. |
| Suspicious personal information | An address that does not match the credit report; an SSN that was never issued or is on the Death Master File; an address that is fictitious, a mail drop or a prison; an SSN or phone number already used by another applicant; missing required information. |
| Unusual account activity | Nonpayment on an account with no history of late payments; repeated returned mail while payments continue; a customer reporting they are not getting statements; notice of unauthorized transactions. |
| Notice from others | A customer, identity theft victim or law enforcement agency tells you an account was opened fraudulently. |
The guidelines list responses that may be appropriate, depending on the risk: monitoring the account, contacting the customer, changing passwords or security codes, not opening the account, closing an existing account, not attempting to collect or not selling the account to a debt collector, notifying law enforcement, or deciding no response is warranted.
Address discrepancy notices from credit bureaus
A separate rule covers what you do when a credit bureau tells you the address you submitted is substantially different from the address in its file. You must have reasonable policies and procedures to form a reasonable belief that the report belongs to your applicant, for example by comparing it with your own records or verifying it with the consumer.
If you can form that belief, establish a continuing relationship with the consumer, and regularly furnish information to that credit bureau, you must also send the bureau an address you have reasonably confirmed, as part of your regular reporting for that period.
Which version applies depends on who regulates you. The FTC’s version (16 C.F.R. Part 641) covers motor vehicle dealers excluded from Consumer Financial Protection Bureau jurisdiction under 12 U.S.C. § 5519. That exclusion does not reach a dealer’s line of business that extends retail credit directly to consumers on contracts not routinely assigned to an unaffiliated finance source, which describes many BHPH dealers. The CFPB’s Regulation V (12 C.F.R. § 1022.82) imposes the same address discrepancy duties on users of consumer reports outside that exclusion. Either way, the duties are the same in substance.
Red Flags Rule vs. Safeguards Rule
| Red Flags Rule | Safeguards Rule | |
|---|---|---|
| Regulation | 16 C.F.R. Part 681 (Fair Credit Reporting Act) | 16 C.F.R. Part 314 (Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act) |
| Problem it addresses | Someone using a stolen identity to open or use an account | Unauthorized access to customer information you hold |
| Written document | Identity Theft Prevention Program | Information security program |
| Typical tools | ID checks, credit report alerts, address verification, account monitoring | Access controls, encryption, multifactor authentication, testing, incident response |
The Safeguards Rule (16 C.F.R. Part 314) sets standards for safeguards that protect the security, confidentiality and integrity of customer information. It does not tell you how to spot an impostor at the desk. The Red Flags Rule does not tell you how to secure your systems. A financing dealer usually needs both programs. Read our guide to the FTC Safeguards Rule for car dealers for that side.
Getting started
- Write down whether you are a creditor and whether you offer or maintain covered accounts, and why.
- Pick the red flags from Supplement A that fit how your customers apply and pay, plus any fraud you have already seen.
- Write the detection step for each: who checks, when, and against what.
- Write the response for each, including when to stop a deal and who decides.
- Have the owner or a senior manager approve the program in writing.
- Train everyone who takes applications or payments.
- List your service providers that touch accounts and set expectations in their contracts.
- Put a yearly review on the calendar.
Detection is easier when the application, the deal and the account history sit in one place. NetDealer keeps customer records, deals and contracts and BHPH accounts with payment history together, with unlimited users on the web and mobile app. The program itself, and the judgment calls in it, belong to your dealership.
Frequently asked questions
Does the Red Flags Rule apply to Buy Here Pay Here dealers?
Usually. A BHPH dealer that regularly pulls credit reports, reports to credit bureaus or carries its own installment contracts generally meets the statutory definition of creditor, and an automobile loan is one of the rule’s examples of a covered account. Confirm your status with counsel.
What are the four elements of an Identity Theft Prevention Program?
Reasonable policies and procedures to identify relevant red flags, detect them, respond appropriately to prevent and mitigate identity theft, and update the program periodically.
Who has to approve the program at a small dealership?
The rule requires board approval of the initial written program. For a creditor without a board of directors, the board means a designated employee at the level of senior management, such as the owner or general manager.
Is the Red Flags Rule the same as the Safeguards Rule?
No. The Red Flags Rule is about detecting identity theft in connection with covered accounts. The Safeguards Rule is about protecting the customer information you keep. A financing dealer usually needs a written program for each.
One customer record
Keep the deal, the customer and the account together.
NetDealer keeps customer records, deals and contracts, and BHPH accounts in one system, on the web and in the mobile app. Book a demo to see how it is organized.
Sources
Reviewed November 18, 2026. Vendor information can change; check each source for current details.
- eCFR, 16 C.F.R. Part 681, Identity Theft Rules
- eCFR, 16 C.F.R. Part 641, Duties of Users of Consumer Reports Regarding Address Discrepancies
- eCFR, 12 C.F.R. § 1022.82, Duties of users regarding address discrepancies
- Legal Information Institute, 15 U.S.C. § 1681m, Requirements on users of consumer reports
- Legal Information Institute, 15 U.S.C. § 1691a, Equal Credit Opportunity Act definitions
- Legal Information Institute, 15 U.S.C. § 1681s, Administrative enforcement
- GovInfo, Public Law 111-319, Red Flag Program Clarification Act of 2010
- Legal Information Institute, 12 U.S.C. § 5519, Exclusion for auto dealers
- eCFR, 16 C.F.R. Part 314, Standards for Safeguarding Customer Information
Related NetDealer pages
Related articles
- Best BHPH Software for Dealers in 2026
How US Buy Here Pay Here dealers should compare BHPH software: accounts, collections, payments, insurance, cost, and what to ask in a demo. Not a ranked list.
- How to Start a Buy Here Pay Here Car Lot (2026 Guide)
Licenses, capital, federal rules and the day-to-day work of starting a Buy Here Pay Here dealership, with links to the FTC, CFPB and state sources.
- FTC Safeguards Rule for Car Dealers: What It Requires
Which car dealers the FTC Safeguards Rule covers, the elements of the required information security program, the small-dealer exception and breach reporting.
- IRS Form 8300 for Car Dealers: Cash Over $10,000
When a car dealer must file IRS Form 8300: what counts as cash, related and installment payments, the 15-day deadline, e-filing and the customer statement.
